| Year | Winner | Nationality | Sport | Achievement |
|---|
| 1954 | Roger Bannister | Great Britain | Track and field | First sub-four-minute mile |
| 1955 | Johnny Podres | United States | Baseball | World SeriesMVP |
| 1956 | Bobby Morrow | United States | Track and field | Triple Olympic gold medalist |
| 1957 | Stan Musial | United States | Baseball | National Leaguebatting champion |
| 1958 | Rafer Johnson | United States | Track and field | Decathlon world record |
| 1959 | Ingemar Johansson | Sweden | Boxing | World Heavyweight Champion |
| 1960 | Arnold Palmer | United States | Golf | PGA Player of the Year |
| 1961 | Jerry Lucas | United States | College basketball | Final FourMVP |
| 1962 | Terry Baker | United States | College football | Heisman Trophy winner |
| 1963 | Pete Rozelle | United States | Professional football | NFL Commissioner; credited for expansion and the suspension of athletes for gambling |
| 1964 | K
|